Mento Magic?

I’d heard about the crazy reaction that’s meant to happen when you put Mentos in Diet Coke (see the link for a great video – just skip the ad) and had even bought some stuff to do it last Summer.  This included a couple of bottles of 7-Up and Extra Strong Mints for a staged ‘disappointing’ first attempt.  As we’d not got around to doing it yet, I thought I’d do it for some half-term wow-factor.

In the video, the girl only put FIVE Mentos in the coke.  So we went for it and put TWO WHOLE PACKETS in.

We did the planned ‘disappointing’ one first, with the 7-Up / Extra Strong Mints, but unfortunately the mints were too big for the bottle opening, so we used Mentos instead – but got (reassuringly) no reaction.

Then we moved on to the main event.  We did one Diet Coke bottle at a time (to eek-out the fun).  I gave the instructions (“chuck ‘em all in and then leg-it”). The reaction from the bottle?  Nothing.  Ab-sol-ute-ly no-th-in-g.

My eldest even shook the bottle in the style of a Formula One driver.  Still nothing. We’d aimed for a magical Mento moment, what we got was a fizzy flop:

mento-2

Google “why didn’t my Mentos and coke fountain work?” and seems I’m not alone.  I’m in a parallel universe with this other parent who posted:

“I stood there like an idiot with all the little kids looking up expectantly at me, (with my carefully given out swimming goggles on) shoveled in the Mentos and nothing happened!!!”

Apparently we’d both been been scuppered by science:

Mythbusters reported that when flavored Mentos with a smooth waxy coating were tested in carbonated drink there was hardly a reaction, whereas standard Mentos added to carbonated drink formed an energetic eruption, affirming the nucleation-site theory”

I’m not a big Mento connoisseur or anything, but I think ours had a smooth coating.  The Extra Strong Mints with their pitted surface may have been the answer after all.  So close, yet so very far.  Alternatively, there’s always the potential that our ingredients had somehow passed their sell-by date (if that’s possible…?).

Either way, this calls for re-trials.  Ignoring the possibility that it’s just an advertiser’s ruse to buy more mints and coke, I’m not going to let this beat me.

And if it fails again? … well, I also saw the following advice:

“Next time try a lump of metallic potassium and some liquid oxygen. It doesn’t half go with a bang!”

Now, call me chicken, but I think I’ll be giving that one a miss, even with swimming goggles.

 

2 thoughts on “Mento Magic?

  1. I made a bottle rocket for the kids with the help of a football pump, a wine cork, and a plastic bottle half-full of water. Apart from getting completely covered in water, and losing the bottle over a neighbourhood fence during a mis-fire, it worked spectacularly.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Now that sounds good – bet your kids loved it. Altho I’m now thinking this science-stuff is a bit beyond me. My kids were entertained, just not in the way I’d intended – it was such a damp squib that they just laughed at me. I’ll google the rocket-thing tho, I’m sure they’d like that…

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s